Although I often use terms like "third world" and "developing" in my speech and writing in the interest of simplifying communication, I find these terms problematic. While I admit that I have seen India literally developing before my eyes during my 7 months here, the idea that a country is "developing" implies that they must try to become like "us" - as if they development were a linear process and and each country falls somewhere on that line. The term also implies that one developed nation is superior, while another developing or undeveloped country is behind, lacking, inferior, or, as they say in India, "backwards."
I take issue with the idea that one place is backwards while another is not. People create a mental link between the idea of infrastructural development and the idea of moral development, and moral, political, and structural development. In their minds, and in the discourse and terminology used, developing country = developing people. We read about people dying of AIDS, malaria, getting hit by buses, women burned alive by husbands, children trafficked for sex tourism purposes (as if these problems don't happen in the "developed" world). But yes, there are many problems with corruption and lack of infrastructure in India, which often has detrimental results for citizens, including in sickness, death, acute poverty, failure of aid to reach those for whom it is intended, and a host of other problems.
Modi, the head of the Indian state of
Gujarat (and was also chief minister during the
Gujarat riots and has been criticized for his role in this) whom an Indian coworker once equated with Hitler, perhaps admitted to killing his opponent and justified it saying he deserved it and he did what needed to be done.
But what about the developed world? Is there such a vast distinction in policies and attitudes of our politicians? Several days ago when I read that Bush vetoed an anti-torture bill, or "interrogation limits" for the CIA, these questions were what ran through my mind. I know that "water-boarding" has gotten a lot of attention in recent months, but the others are equally if not more disturbing to me.
This list is taken from a
BBC article on Bush's recent veto of the anti-torture bill.
CIA 'ENHANCED INTERROGATION' TECHNIQUES
Water-boarding: prisoner bound to a board with feet raised, and cellophane wrapped round his head. Water is poured onto his face and is said to produce a fear of drowning
Cold cell: prisoner made to stand naked in a cold, though not freezing, cell and doused with water
Standing: Prisoners stand for 40 hours and more, shackled to the floor
Belly slap: a hard slap to the stomach with an open hand. This is designed to be painful but not to cause injury
My point is not exactly that India is not developing, or that America is more backward than it pretends... let's just say that in my opinion, Bush and Modi are in a similar camp.