Saturday, December 1, 2007

"Can I ask you about your dot?"

After work, I was walking to the bus with Anu, who lives near my neighborhood. She was saying that I would be the center of attention when I went to the communalism workshop in the village of Mahbubnagar. I told her I don't mind when women and children stare at me, because the women generally smile back when I smile at them, and the kids like to say "hi! hi! hi!" and are super cute. It's the men staring that bothers me, because it is creepy and if I were to smile at them, as I do with the women, it would be interpreted disturbingly incorrectly. I know I'm a foreigner, I told her, but I still don't like the assumption that I am rich/easy/exciting just because I am a white woman. Why do all these men have to stare at me?

Anu was silent for a moment, and then asked me what would happen if an Indian woman came to America - would they get similar treatment?

"Oh no," I said. "They might stare, but it would be less sexual and more just because she was different... and we might talk louder to her, even if she spoke perfect English because people who speak English with an Indian accent are assumed to be intermediate in their English-speaking abilities, and ask her if 'Indian' was her first language... and we might institutionally discr iminate against her, but just a little, and somewhat subtly... and we might not stare so overtly in public, but instead fetishize her... And if it were an Indian Muslim women who wore a Burqa we would definitely stare, and comment in an airport that she would be thoroughly searched, because she is likely a suicide bomber, or part of an islamofacist terrorist mutiny, and talk openly about how oppressed she was by her men because she has to wear that awful thing, because clearly no woman would ever willingly choose such a burden, and...

"Oh."

5 comments:

dragonlord785 said...

that's a pretty interesting conversation you had there; the pictures are nice :)

Robin said...

Myla,

How long are you going to be in hyderabad? I'm really trying to make a summer India trip happen.

I may teach in Kerala for a month and then visit Calcutta (friend) and try to get over to delhi.

but its great to see what you're doing; and your pix are great.

Robin

Anonymous said...

hi Myla! Really interesting and insightful comments. In the end, who is worse off? Love, Rachelle

Anonymous said...

Hi Myla,
I know many women who dont know the concept of Hijab think muslim women are oppressed. But it is not so. Hijab is modest dressing, not remaining in the background. Wearing a hijab myself, i want to be spoken to and looked at as a person and not at my feminine mould which is more often done. I would not want men to look/stare/judge my womanly endowment or be an object of lustful gazing.
It is a different matter that muslim are oppressed like any other woman anywhere in the world, but beleive me it is not because of the burqa she wears.
During ur stay in Hyderabad dint u cee women in burqa driving cars or two wheelers?

Anonymous said...

Good post.

my space counters Travel Top Blogs

About Me

United States
I wrote this blog while working at a women's resource center in Hyderabad, India through a social justice fellowship through American Jewish World Service.

When I think of India, I think of...

I would like Planet Bollywood better if it had: